Additionally, a state court jury’s multimillion dollar verdict against Navistar in a similar case was reversed. Conversely, class plaintiffs estimated lost resale value damages at more than $9,000 a truck. The objectors calculated diminished truck values of up to nearly $27,000 per truck with a MaxxForce engine. Courts do not have the authority to rewrite a settlement during the final approval process.” Objectors have not explained why such a victory would be fair or how the court could rewrite the settlement as they propose. The line of action is a simple curved line that evokes movement. “The proposal does not so much represent a compromise between the positions of Navistar and the class as it does a victory for the class. Making the line of action curved, as opposed to drawing it as a straight line, gives your character's pose more force and attitude which, in turn, aids in making your character's poses more visually interesting to the viewer. Explaining the decision, the court wrote: However, the judge overruled those objections. The four companies consider the agreement “inadequate and unfair for failing to compensate class members for any lost truck value,” according to their filed objection. In October, Ferguson Enterprises, Southern California Edison Co., The Walt Disney Co., and US Foods objected to the proposed settlement. Approval comes approximately three months after four large fleets objected to the proposed MaxxForce settlement. The remaining $50 million will go toward payments under the rebate option. Navistar will allocate $85 million to the cash and “prove up” options. “Prove up” option: The class member submits documentary evidence of damages for “covered expenses” totaling no more than $15,000.The 10-truck cap was intended to prevent the claims of class members with large fleets from depleting the funds for the other options. The settlement limits this option to no more than 10 trucks per class member. The class member must prove the length of ownership or lease. Rebate option: A rebate of up to $10,000 toward the purchase of a new Navistar truck.No proof of damages is needed, though the class member must prove the length of qualified ownership of a class truck.
Cash option: A lump sum payment of up to $2,500.Per the agreement, class members have three options to recover losses: